Shine Bright is likely more advanced than where the young man is.  My advice is to draw up a private message explaining that his behavior and penmanship aren't acceptable.  He needs to build himself up before joining your board and anyone else's board.  I'd do this compassionately.  You seem like a wonderful administrator, @dreams .  If the fellow goes beserk, punish and continue.

As far as obscure ideas and plots are concerned, employing them often contributes new feels and learning on the community's end.  However, I think an applicant should go over his or her plan with whoever is running a game they're interested in joining.  I do so sans fail myself.  My own character is a sixteen-year-old sopranista who sings opera.  It bores most people, so he's a difficult fit.