write a reply

Staffing Confessions

Tidal Wave
aliasAkira, Tsunami, Tsu, Aki
pronounsAny
4,225written posts
AkiraTsunamiearned bits
offlinecurrently
AkiraTsunami
Part of the Furniture
AkiraTsunami Avatar
I've got a hurricane in my head, I can't feel a thing, but it's better than dead
I wish I could like the above post 8 million times.

To be fair, some people do get frustrated about it, it's the need to be perfect in some people I think. But at the same time, 100%... Admins and staff exist to help people find their footing. Losing frustrated newbies is not exactly a loss. I would rather someone ask me a ton of questions about the lore or clarifications about the rules or whatever, than have anyone pretend they understand everything and then get mad when they don't.

phantom of the black parade
pronounsshe / her pronouns
4,377written posts
Kuroyaearned bits
offlinecurrently
Kuroya
Part of the Furniture
Kuroya Avatar
what do you want to know? my height, hobbies, quirks, the color of my underwear?
ngl, a part of me is sorely tempted to try out a semi-public "sponsorship" model for a site, just to see if it would genuinely improve the overall site experience for everyone by trying to pre-emptively avoid the situation of "newbie joins + leaves almost immediately because no one is mega hyped to thread with their poorly integrated rando" (which, to be 100000% clear, i do not blame them for, i would leave too - and have left - if i was in their shoes)

then i remember that want ads + buddy requests don't tend to get taken all that often and people probably wouldn't update a "sponsorship form" to hype up all the stuff they'd be interested in doing with new people, so i chuck the idea in the bin to rot :skull:
last edit on May 14, 2023 21:36:27 GMT by Kuroya

phantom of the black parade
pronounsshe / her pronouns
4,377written posts
Kuroyaearned bits
offlinecurrently
Kuroya
Part of the Furniture
Kuroya Avatar
what do you want to know? my height, hobbies, quirks, the color of my underwear?
AkiraTsunami Avatar
can you pretty please explain what you mean by sponsorship model? I might be stupid or out of date because I have 0 idea what that means.


i mean. lol it's not exactly a thing in rp. (closest we get is probably rl "private" sites with temporary open enrollment periods but otherwise run invite-only.)

the idea is that more or less new members wouldn't be able to join without having a specific established member to hook onto + plot with to help with integrating into the community. this could be used not just with want ads + explicit invites from friends but alongside little "sponsor forms" that current members could fill out with a list of their current characters, some stuff they'd explicitly want to do with their current roster, and additional stuff they'd pick up if someone else was interested (so that people don't have to go on a fishing expedition just to find someone willing to plot with them + thus "sponsor" them).

basically, it's just a minor guard rail to try to help actually integrate new people into the site by pushing them to find one (1) solidly established plotting partner before they go running off into the wild making characters that might not have a decent enough plotting foundation to give them engaging threads for participants (on both sides) to get invested in.

(it probably works a lil better in my neck of the woods, because panfans tend to place most of their high-engagement plotting with castmates and/or rp friends since there's a solid chemistry to build off of either icly or oocly, but i think it's not the worst way to try to ensure a new member has a "new site buddy" to help integrate them in a way that's a bit more pointed than trying to plot in a void with people who may or may not be all that invested in whether or not the person ends up sticking around)
last edit on May 15, 2023 1:44:51 GMT by Kuroya

aliasFrosty
pronouns*shrugs*
177written posts
«Fr¤§t¥»earned bits
offlinecurrently
«Fr¤§t¥»
Full Member
«Fr¤§t¥» Avatar
On my Devil May Cry shtick again
Need to find someone who loves advertising so much, I can bring them on as a staff member specifically as a RP/advertiser person. -Cackles maniacally into the distant void at the thought of someone like that actually existing.-
aliashannyfish
pronounsshe/they
248written posts
hannyearned bits
offlinecurrently
hanny
Full Member
hanny Avatar
「我等の天下だ 神など要らない。」
Not sure if this is one that's been beaten over the head a million times, but I do have a tendency to try and thread with at least everyone as a staffer, even if I end up not enjoying it. It just feels right to if I have the ability to be able to.
Tidal Wave
aliasAkira, Tsunami, Tsu, Aki
pronounsAny
4,225written posts
AkiraTsunamiearned bits
offlinecurrently
AkiraTsunami
Part of the Furniture
AkiraTsunami Avatar
I've got a hurricane in my head, I can't feel a thing, but it's better than dead
Kuroya Avatar
AkiraTsunami Avatar
can you pretty please explain what you mean by sponsorship model? I might be stupid or out of date because I have 0 idea what that means.
-removed chunk above because its right there.-



oooohhh I getcha. This is kinda what we're doing atm. already have to know someone and want to work with someone in the tiny circle or plots already worked out with certain people in order to join in. though not entirely like that, some are invited at random and have literally nothing to do with rp because we only really just hangout 99% of the time posting bad memes.

However I do think that something like that could potentially work as long as you start out with a decent amount of people that know a decent amount of people. It's basically just private, invite only but with extra steps.

thanks for explaining!

Tidal Wave
aliasAkira, Tsunami, Tsu, Aki
pronounsAny
4,225written posts
AkiraTsunamiearned bits
offlinecurrently
AkiraTsunami
Part of the Furniture
AkiraTsunami Avatar
I've got a hurricane in my head, I can't feel a thing, but it's better than dead
ah yes. the virtual coin flippers. the decider of all fates.

no really.

we use coin flips and dice rolls and t!choose for like... everything. every important plot decision every fork in the road. Sometimes it's best to just leave things up to chance rather than plotting everything out to every minute detail. Makes it more fun that way.

176written posts
zeroearned bits
offlinecurrently
zero
Full Member
zero Avatar
Incoming rant because I’ve had a bad day:

I think we make a mistake in calling the people who run sites ‘staff’. Staff implies employment. It implies servitude. It implies that we are there to be at the beck and call of members at all times. It leads people to feel they can treat us however they fancy because we are there to serve them and provide them an experience.

News flash, we are not. We are roleplayers who have decided to create a world we want to write in, and we’ve chosen to invite others to join us in that world. We get to pick the rules. We get to decide how it runs. But we also get to decide who is in our world and, news flash again, players are not entitled to be there. The better term for us would be authors. Authors with our assistants, who are there to create a world, to share it with others, and to write and tell our own stories. Not staff on hand to serve.

In my opinion, these attitudes are why sites close so quickly these days. It’s fine at first. Seems fun. You set up a site thinking an idea would be fun. You create the world, come up with some rules, create some ideas. You invite people in. They have qs. You happily answer. They have apps. You give them a look to make sure they fit your world. Maybe you have a gander at creating a site plot for others to engage in. You come up with some events. It’s all cool.

But slowly, over time, you find that instead of role-playing, you’ve become a 24/7 help desk, putting on a customer service face, trying to settle disputes and questions, dealing with assholes who don’t care about your well-being or boundaries, who get mad at you if you’re not progressing the site plot like you’re being paid to handhold their experience, and it’s like ‘fuck, why am I even running this world when I don’t get to write in it?’

It needs to change. We should not be holding site authors to these standards, and we should not be demanding extreme professionalism and customer service care from an amateur, hobbyist activity. And we should stop calling people who run them staff. Period. Call them authors. Architects. Volunteers. Whatever you fancy. (I quite like architect.) But they are not employees at a player’s beck and call, and they should not be referred to that way. When we open a site, we invite others into that world. Players are not entitled to that access. That invitation should be treated with more respect. And so should site authors.

This has been my grumpy ted talk. Thank you for coming.
aliasavanhellica, avan, nyx
pronounsthey / she
133written posts
avanearned bits
offlinecurrently
avan
Full Member
avan Avatar
she's the wicked witch of the EAST bro
zero Avatar
snipped for length


I completely agree and sympathize with you.

This is why I've opted to make all of my personal projects moving forward semi-private. My friends are welcome. Friends of my friends are welcome, and so on, because it avoids me from having to deal with people who think like that. It encourages the collaborativeness of people to communicate and work together to help expand upon the world that was initially created.

And if for some reason someone gets invited in who is toxic/not following the rules? Boom. They're gone. I'm not putting up with that shit anymore. I already have to do customer service for my job, I don't want to do it for my hobby too.

Definitely +1ing the word Architect.

last edit on Jul 1, 2023 14:36:01 GMT by avan
aliasSola
pronounsthey/he
219written posts
Solaearned bits
offlinecurrently
Sola
Full Member
Sola Avatar
Tell me which you dread more ; the echo or the answer?
My biggest pet peeve is when you have like open occupations or positions for established groups within a world and someone tries to take it, but the amount of years that they've either been around (for a panfandom), or in that position previously just don't line up with what you have in mind. 
I hate to stomp my foot down and to establish that sort of thing so it stops happening but it just... if you're going to be the leader of a group I feel like you should have established yourself within the area or in the job category. No one is just going to give you that position because you claim to know how to do it. That's not how this works, that not how any of this works. 

On a happier note, I'm glad to have established a community where staffers warn their members when a character is up for deletion so someone can save their information before the character is deleted. 
I highly suggest sites start doing that. I don't know how many times i've forgotten to save info for a character and suddenly it's completely gone because no one warned me. 
last edit on Jul 1, 2023 15:05:10 GMT by Sola
0written posts
Deletedearned bits
offlinecurrently
Deleted
Deleted Avatar


I don't normally post, but I just wanted to say that I also fully sympathize. I've done my best being a moderator, trying to be as patient and readily available as I know how, yet there will always be people who take every little thing as a massive slight against them and then they'll complain about "professionalism."

It's not a job. I'm not a professional. I don't get paid, but rather I pay into my site out of pocket (Jcink premium, site skin, etc). I'm doing the best I can, and trying to learn from my mistakes; to work on new skills every day to try and accommodate others. Yet, it's not good enough for some people (I say some, because I'd say a good chunk of RPers are a lot more understanding and forgiving while there'll always be those who will use anything as fuel to incriminate staff in some way). They still carry unrealistic expectations.

Then there comes a time where some people will expect a site to be exactly the way they want it when in reality, I - as a site creator - don't even get everything I want from the site I made. Why? Because I have to consider more than just one person, more than just me. I have to consider everyone.

I agree with the sentiment that we built our sites for ourselves and invite others into it. Personally, I do this to meet new people and make new friends. It's my social activity, my hobby, my downtime. When my downtime becomes as stressful (or even more stressful) than my actual job, there's a problem.

I also like architects, but I'm not sure if that eliminates the issue of "we're not paid," because some people will take it as the occupational definition which is paid. Still, it might be better than "staff" on its own. I think some people naturally have issues with "figures of authority," so something like "Architect" might help eliminate that "authoritative" vibe. I'm not sure.

I might try this out, though, as a social project and see if it helps any. If anyone else tries it, I'd be curious to hear about the results.

aliasantiviral
pronounsHe/Him
250written posts
Beetleearned bits
offlinecurrently
Beetle
Senior Member
Beetle Avatar

I empathize with how hard being staff on a site can be, but I have to agree with 11's sentiment that it's not an issue of title. At the end of the day, regardless of what you call it, the people in charge of a site are in charge of the site whether you call them staff, admins, moderators, dungeon masters, architects, etc.

When you create a group, you take on the responsibilities that entails which, in the case of a roleplay, are to help the members you've invited into your group. This includes answering questions, settling disputes, and making sure the group functions as intended. This is true for any group whether it be a TTRPG with you and four friends or a roleplay forum with 100+ members.

It can be rough, and thankless, and some people do expect way too much of administrators, but an important part of running any group is setting boundaries. If you feel like you've become a 24/7 help desk, set clear expectations on when members can expect help from you. Pick a day of the week, or a time frame like 48 hours. Alternatively, it might be easier to invite others to help moderate to lessen that load a bit so the responsibility isn't all on you.

Worst case scenario, like you said, members are not entitled to a place on your site. Kick 'em out if they aren't respecting boundaries or are entitled.

tl;dr Even if it's unpaid, and a hobby, making the decision to run a group is also making the decision to become a community leader and accepting the responsibilities that come with that. Changing the name isn't going to change that. The only real way to reduce the number of entitled members is to set clear expectations and cut out anyone who can't respect that.

It's not an us vs them situation. I've run into disrespectful members when I've been a moderator and admins who use the "it's just a hobby" mentality to excuse incredibly disrespectful behaviour when I've been a member. It's a complicated and nuanced issue that changes from community to community.

Solar Waltz, an 18+ panfandom set in NYC