pronounsshe/her
1,847written posts
offlinecurrently
stressed, depressed, and probably not well-dressed
You do you, s'all good. xD If it's MFC, I have no problems with it. But if it's an RL FC only site using animanga graphics (or the reverse: an animanga only FC site using RL graphics), it feels like false advertisement. I'm not really into using RL FCs anymore and a few times I've stumbled on these really cute animanga-graphicy forums and yet they only allowed RL FCs. I'm sure people who prefer using RL over animanga FCs feel the same way when they see a forum use RL graphics but only allow animanga FCs. xD
In my opinion, the look of your forum should immediately tell your viewers what its it is bare-basics wise. At an initial glance, animanga graphics is going to look like an animanga FC site. RL graphics is going to look like a RL FC site. Mixed FCs is obviously the most flexible. I guess the best way I can describe it is if a high fantasy book had a super hardcore scifi image as its cover. Scifi lovers will pick it up based on the cover and read the back, but as soon as they see it's high fantasy and not scifi, they'll put the book down and be like "okay, bye." You will, of course, get the occasional person who doesn't care. But for the most part, it's just bad representation.
I don't have to have MFC to do that. If someone can't read the site or read the plot to see if it's animanga/rl/mfc, what have you, then I don't really want them on site cause they didn't read. If an image screws up your view on the site, that sounds pretty narrow to be honest. That's like saying you can't use video game art or realistic art for your hover image cause it doesn't fit with the site or something. I haven't met a single person (Beyond you, obviously) that has felt like they've been tricked. I understand that it's your opinion and that's fine. However, as you can see by my response and others, your opinion is your opinion and that's okay. However, you didn't phrase it as an opinion, you phrased it as a must and there's no other option/reason. I was just joshing with it, not targeting you with it, which is why I didn't quote you. You're free to feel and do what you think. However, in my opinion. Graphics are graphics and if I want to use something, I will, and not be locked down in some arbitrary medium when I can use everything I can to put forward my vision on a skin or site. If people don't like it, that's fine. They don't have to join. If someone wants a pure image type of site, they can join that one or make that one. As a web designer, I applaud anyone who makes a skin - and puts forward their imagination onto code. If someone wants purity, then they can aim for that. I don't want to and others might not feel the same as you. In other news I slept for way too long. Why did I sleep like 15 hours. I didn't need to.
|
|